The Iemma government hired a British transportation expert , Jim Steer, to review their Metro trains project. Unsurprisingly h
e found it a waste of money:
The document, obtained by the Herald , demolishes the metro proposal and the “optimistic” assumptions underpinning it.
It raises serious questions about the key transport commitment on which Morris Iemma has staked his Government’s future.
Written by Jim Steer, a world-leading transport consultant and executive with Britain’s former Strategic Rail Authority, the Sydney Transport Review report says the planned 38-kilometre Euro-style subway – from Rouse Hill to St James Station – is too long to be viable as a metro, is predicated on a poor business case and will do little to alleviate the CityRail congestion crisis.”
As it stands, it would seem that more harm than good would accrue to Sydney and its economy from proceeding with the project,” it says….
But of course the government has ignored the review, at least publicly:
Mr Watkins confessed he did not think “Jim Steer knew much about Sydney”, despite being paid to conduct the report.
“I have to say I met him in London in December. He had very little knowledge at that time of Sydney’s rail network or road network. I actually remember drawing both for him on a piece of paper,” he said.
“I think he’d visited Sydney once before.”
Then why was he hired Mr Watkins?
From the Premier’s office we get:
Justin Kelly, a spokesman for the Premier said: “Mr Steer’s work did not adequately address the question of how to deliver on the Government’s election commitment to deliver rail services to the north-west by 2015. The Government has a clear commitment to deliver rail services to Castle Hill by 2015 and Rouse Hill by 2017. So when advice was received that took it away from the plan we’d outlined to the people of the north-west, it was never going to be accepted….
Was he ever asked to provide an alternative? I expect the Metro project will last a bit longer but eventually die. Properly when Labor dumps Iemma the Incompetent.